Mikedisappointed Hole in middle of back panel. Dreadful. First time out the box it felt so thin it would fall apart. And lo and behold as I put it on I found a hole already in the back. No where near a seam. Just in the middle of the cloth. Sent it back.

Kenthgghgfghf Buy size up Not true to size, too short and much smaller than similar items of same size

sue4seaside Hopefully excellent. I am trusting that this jumper is as perfect as I always expect from goods bought from M&S, as I bought it as a Christmas gift for someone special.

Deaf Bat A bit disappointed Bought online. Much thinner material than what I was expecting.

tedrick Terrific Cardi! Very pleased with the purchase of this item. I have always had cashmere woolies until now, but this yarn is so soft and comfortable that I can barely tell the difference. Highly recommended.

KG14 Best cardigan ever This is the 2nd cardigan I've purchased in this range for my partner. Lovely quality and true fit

MJ2001 Classic piece Lovely and soft fabric and very smart, great colour

Beth A L Well made Well made , nice quality very fine knit as described

Tim LM Derbyshire Extra fine wool cardigan Disappointing as not as warm as expected but otherwise fine.

MA36 Great Cardigan Lovely quality wool and a very good fit too. Excellent for a smart casual look.

Michaelgt Great fit Great fit, but why don't you have the cardigan instore....

Stormy Weathers Sizing Issues Not as descibed, measured (with a tape) smaller than published dimensions for XL. The cardigan was tight fitting across the chest, shoulders and biceps. I returned for a full refund and bought an alternative elsewhere.

Good lad Rob Nice and stylish fir a 77 year old. Lovely wool and stylish. Hugs my gut tight which i dont like but thats my problem.

Chris cardi Nice feel and quality Nice quality warm good for when it is chilly but not thick enough for a v cold day

pchocs Arm friendly Light and comfortable, stylish and arm friendly. Easy to care for

Punchesgirl Smart cardigan! Bought as a gift. The recipient loved it and thought is was good quality and fitted true to size

Old Kate To dark . Soft to the touch and sizing good .X-Large fits my husband perfectly .Losing a star because the colour is a very dark grey ,almost black .Why do men’s cardigans are made only in dark colours ? It would be nice if they were produced in lighter colours similar to the summer jumper range .

Syd J Easy to weat easy to wash Lovely cardigan, bought fir my dad who already has one in another colour. Washes well, keeps itsshape, can even get away with not ironing it.

Sorry nameless East to wear, great quality and style I'm very pleased with the merino cardigan I bought for my husband's birthday – better still, he's delighted with it and wearing it as often as he can

J Sebastian Blockley Made in Myanmar and of questionable quality. The fit is poor. There are no pockets. It is a different (inferior) texture and dissimilar colour to the extra fine merino wool polo shirt I bought at the same time with which to pair it. It is "Made in Myanmar". Really? Shame on you Marks and Spencer! I will have to reconsider if I purchase any more garments from M&S in future if the company has become so unaware and unprincipled.