The ultimate guide to the best mince pies

At M&S, our product developers have tasted hundreds of mince pies in their quest to create the perfect one. Whether you’re going traditional, gluten-free or fancy trying something new, read our guide to the best mince pies in the Foodhall this Christmas.

Food Editor

Olivia Ferguson

3 mince pie flavour hacks

1. Cheeseboard mince pies

Carefully remove the lid from an M&S Classic All Butter Pastry Mince Pie and add a slice of Colston Basset Stilton. Replace the lid and bake at 180°C fan/200°C/gas mark 6 for 10 minutes, until warmed through and the cheese has started to melt.

2. Black forest mince pies

Top our Collection Triple Cherry Mince Pies (in store from 1 November) with a spoonful of Collection Cornish Clotted Cream and a drizzle of Collection Cherries in Kirsch. Finish with dark chocolate shavings.

3. Brown butter crème fraîche mince pie

Top our Collection Mince Pies with brown butter crème fraîche, made by browning 100g unsalted butter, then allowing to cool. Combine with 200g M&S normandy crème fraîche and the zest of an easy peeler. Whip until smooth then serve on top a mince pie – ideally one that's warm!

Published 16/09/2026