AmandaL Fabulous Mascara Great mascara, doesn't clump and stays put. I have tried other brands but always come back to this one - the price and quality are amazing.

Termun Recommended in Saga Disappointed, the mascara wand is quite slim and the mascara clogs onto it in lumps which makes it difficult to apply, especially to thin lashes.

Moobob Worst mascara ever Bought this as read magazine article saying how good it was. It isn't ! It's clumpy and "dry" and now I've wasted £12.50 on buying something I will never use I now see the price has been reduced which upsets me even more

Mumtully Okay product Loved the colour and the small brush which I found better for application than a fatter brush. Good for a less 'made up' look but disappointed that it didn't make my lashes look fuller.

Dazalon Worst Mascara Ever! Dramatic Lashes is impossible to apply evenly, the very thin brush dumps dollops of goo onto eye lashes which won't spread evenly. Blink and it spreads all round your eyes. Would have given no stars if I could.

HelsM Very disappointing - sent back for a refund I always buy Autograph mascaras because they are good value for money and they do a good shade of brown. But this one was terrible. I didn't read other reviews before buying which was clearly a mistake. It is sticky and clumpy. I sent it back for a refund.

SueV3 Dreadful. Horrible to put on. It sticks to your eyelashes and clumps. It claims to be smudge free but was smudged everywhere after an hour.

Ordinaryangel Awful Like a lot of other reviewers I bought this because I thought Autograph would guarantee a quality product. I also made the mistake of not reading the reviews. Unfortunately this is the worst mascara I’ve every used. It’s just a useless sticky mess but for something so sticky the only think it doesn’t stick to is your lashes. Waste of money

Adhoc Disappointing Bought this as never have the one I like but this is awful. My first application was completely clumpy. A waste of money

sexy knickers Present Bought as a present for my daughter, who loves it and can't wait to open the boxes