All About Shadow™ Primer for Eyes 4.7ml

I used this years ago and it was brilliant.The one I bought a few months ago is watery and the foam tip has completely disintegrated. For Clinique you expect and deserve quality, but I'm not going to bother with any of their products from now on. Not worth the money.

I’m usually the second or third palest shade in foundation etc. I got this in “very fair” and it’s way too dark. It’s sheer as well so it doesn’t even out my skin tone or anything. It’s also greasy and doesn’t keep my eye makeup in place. So basically it’s totally useless. Disappointing. I wish I’d bought a cheaper eye primer from another brand or just stuck with concealer.

Very small , won't last very long . Not the best value for money .

I'm guessing the good reviews are from young people. I found it useless. My eye colour still creases, almost immediately. The discontinued stuff was far better.

It does exactly what is say’s it does,I love this eye primer

I purchased this item for the first time before Christmas on a recommendation from M&S staff member and took it away with me on Boxing Day. It appeared to be just about empty by 1st January and frankly, at that price I expect to find more product in the tube. I am an 'ancient' and don't slather vast amounts of makeup on my eyelids, so it certainly wasn't due to overuse!

Exactly what I was expecting and delighted with purchase.

I love this product, it really helps to keep your eye makeup in place. But, it needs to be in a pallet that you can dab with your finger or a brush. Because the silly little dip stick tube doesn't work! All the product gathers at either end and you can't get to it as the sponge on a stick just scrapes the middle section. Very frustrating!

Love the product , hate the packaging. Gives a lovely base or great to wear on its own so thought I'd solved my search for a natural looking day time product. However it's impossible to use all the liquid due to the applicator not reaching the bottom of the tube and even when always kept in a standing position the liquid stays around the edge and at top of tube. So disappointing. Clinique you need to look at how you package products , unfortunately until then I will not be buying again as wastage makes it a very expensive item.

Since the canvas eye base has discontinued this primer is the next best thing. It covers well but I do hate the fact you can never get to the bottom of the tube when it’s nearly finished

I used to buy the old pallet style primer, I'll be honest I bought it for the slight colour it gave and often wore alone. It absolutely did dry out and often I'd replace before I needed to because of this. Wasteful. Last time I bought it the packaging had changed. I use it every day. I dab the applicator onto my lid and then use a wide shadow brush to blend it onto my full lid up to the brow. It smooths and prepares my lid, ensuring excess oils are tackled. It evens the colour on my lid a little too. It's a silky, fine finish and I love it. I use shadow on my lid after and it stays put. Does the job. I've come back to reorder because I've just ran down, scraping the applicator around the tube to get the last bits from the tube - no waste for me. It's a win.

Really disappointed first time I used it. This seemed to be empty of product when I first tried it almost as if it had been used up , have to keep pumping the applicator to get anything out

Have used this product before and loved it, read reviews and knew packaging had changed but thought I would try it. Used it once and experienced a bad allergic reaction. Never had a problem with Clinique products before so very disappointed

Been using this for years, lovely product to create even/no crease eye makeup. Was infinitely better in the pallet though (even though it had a tendancy to dry up over long periods of time). This new packaging has made mine completely unusable after a handful of uses! Cant get any out of the tube. Won't be buying more until the packaging is sorted out. Only Clinique product I've been utterly disappointed by (and I'm a clinique girl).