fojdmoon Poor quality and fit Purchased these because my favourite midis are no longer available. These are not such a good fit. Although the packaging suggests full coverage, they are cut quite high at the back so they do not cover the buttocks. Also the gusset is very narrow. The material is thin too, not sure how long they will last. M&S quality is not what it was, sadly.

JoJums Disappointing I was very disappointed in these. Thin fabric and very narrow in the crotch. Not particularly comfortable to wear. I’ve used two pairs but probably won’t use the others. I bought them as there is not much choice in packs of midi knickers anymore.

Devongran Disappointing While the style is perfect for me, I am disappointed with the fabric. It is very thin, and I felt I might put my finger through it if I wasn't careful, also it's far more stretchy than I expected, and consequently came up huge on me. Since I tried on, I can't return them, but i'll be saving them for emergencies, or in case I put on weight...

Mrs K J C Well recommended!! I read all the reviews about these knickers before I bought them & I ignored all the negative ones, which I now know was the right thing to do. They're nice material, well made & very comfortable. I'm an 18 in knickers & I can say they're true to size. They also wash well. I'm very happy with them!

thelmaS Cotton shorts Good material , good comfortable cut, elastic a bit weak

WaterlooLady Comfortable Good but one was smaller than the others. Comfortable.

Staunton Supima shorts Yes very comfortable and like the lowe rise short knickers I have been used to. Please make single ones again and more choice.

Mecarenoni Stripy Low Rise Cotton Shorts Good value for money and fit well although would like elastic a bit deeper.

Bolton Cotton Low rise shorts Cotton low rise best ones in ages a great improvement on previous low rise shorts well done M&S.

Namibiaisfabulous So very, very uncomfortable I treated myself to these yesterday as they looked promising. HOWEVER! The lack of elastic in the legs means they spend all day riding up where they should not. Yes, l adjusted them lower. Yes, they still rode up. Do not buy these!