The Frances Trench

I found this coat very disappointing. The fabric is great - very good quality and a nice colour, but it was the strangest fit - very boxy, short waisted and ill-fitting across the shoulders. I returrned it immediately.

I had a read a few reviews on here of this coat, so I knew to buy a size smaller than usual. I couldn't find a size 10, so bought this is an 8 (I'm usually a 12) it's still quite roomy but I plan on wearing in the Autumn with a jumper underneath so that's fine, but I think a 6 might have been closer to my size which is a bit crazy! It is a lovely, well designed, excellent quality trench coat though!

I am absolutely thrilled I finally managed to find a size 12 online in the Frances Trench. I am between a 12 and a 14 normally and tried on a 14 in a Manchester store but it was that bit too big, even with a jumper underneath. I waited patiently and checked the website several times a day until I finally found a 12. It is such good quality and super stylish. It looks lovely wrapped and belted without doing the buttons up. It is quite long on me as I'm only 5 ft 3 inches tall but I like the length and it looks good with heeled boots. It is a lovely classic shade of green and the lining adds a traditional touch. The sizing is generous but meant to be oversized so is just right. I've worn it with skinny jeans and tea dresses and it looks equally lovely with both. It will stay in my wardrobe forever.

Classy coat excellent quality, as good as designer brands at Marks & Spencer price. Will last for years a real classic. Also it was good to find a coat with a lining as so many at the moment do not have. Fabulous dark olive green with classic check lining, I love it. I am a size 14 but bought a 12 which is perfect. Thank you M &S.

This is my new favourite coat! It manages to look classic yet current. I've had lots of compliments whilst wearing it

I am so disappointed as this is well made, good quality, excellent priced trench coat with spot on detail such as the check lining. Unfortunately for me it is over sized to the point of unwearable. I tried the 14 my usual size - enormous and then sized down to a 10, slightly better but still big and unflattering. I'm gutted as this is high quality at a good price and then ruined by going for an over size shape.

Been after a good trench for years. Finally found it. Unbelievable quality, looks far more expensive. Unusual colour but looks brilliant on.

I loved this coat when I first saw it online a while ago and was devastated that it was sold out. Was thrilled to find it was available again and even better it coincided with the arrival of my 20% vouchers - it was obviously my lucky day. Have just collected it from my local branch and am delighted with it; the colour, fabric, fit, style - it is just perfect. More like this please M & S. (Could I just say a big thank you to those who have already reviewed this coat, I always read the reviews before ordering anything and, heeding their advice, I went down a size, which is just right.)

A very well-priced trench coat in a flattering shape and colour. Something about the slightly high waist and generous fit makes this a very comfortable and flattering fit for me, which is unusual, as I don't normally choose belted coats. I love the colour, fabric and weight of this and feel fab wearing it. So pleased I happened upon the Alexa Chung collection in my local store.

I've been looking for a cotton classic mac for ages, but I didn't want to pay designer label money ! This khaki coat is great: it's long enough for me at 5'71/2 although waist belt is a little high, it's also not too heavy on, which is another plus , as so many traditional raincoats are sooo uncomfortable. In natural strong cotton it's also not going to be too hot either. This mac is a real winner , and although I was a little unsure of buying khaki ( I'm a navy girl- always) , it's a refreshing change for me and I like it very much. I have worn it with the belt unfastened and I prefer it that way; it's very large but I just sized down and I prefer a looser cut , I also like the raglan style sleeves, as they're so much more flattering -and softer too, when you already have ' shoulders' ! Well done M and S!