Debra E. Eye pen [This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have used these eyeliners for several years. They go on smoothly, are waterproof, and stay on all day long while not smudging. The mulberry is my favorite color.

freddysnannie Super smooth eyeliner great quality product Excellent item, great colour, and glides on smoothly

Sarah K. too soft to apply i love the colors, but after sharpening these pencils they were too soft to apply! the tips of the pencils just break off when i try to put on my eyeliner, which just makes a big mess. i don’t want to have to put them in the freezer before every single application, so i’m not sure what to do about them.

Tollcross90 Another new eye liner to try First PIXI product I have bought so will see how it lasts

stylishshopper2014 Not for me. It's a lovely colour and really does stay put. However, I find that I have already wasted a lot of the pencil trying to sharpen the tip. The tip is very soft (even after putting it in the fridge). The tip is forever getting accidentally flattened and the sharpener has to come out again. It's probably just me being awkward, but I wouldn't buy it again.

Myoma M. Amazing color [This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I bought the black cocoa and it really makes my green eyes sparkle.

Annieonline Best eye pencil ever This eye pencil is so soft to apply yet stays put all day and is easy to remove at night. It doesn’t irritate my eyes. I chose the bronze colour to start with and shall be buying some different shades as I am so pleased with it.

Katie N. So smooth!! [This review was collected as part of a promotion.] When they say silky, they mean it! This glides on so smooth! The only thing that would make it perfect is to have a blender on the end to help even it out.

Dorothy D. Awesome Eye Pen [This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I can’t even tell you how many years I’ve used this brand of Eye Pen...mostly in the black colors, but finally got brave and have tried a few others. Nothing compares to these Eye Pens!

Connie D. Refills needs work I love the color and how long it stays on but to get the pen to refill does NOT work!!! I’m so upset!! I just got one use out of it!