Madam Noir Favourite eyeliner! This is an amazing eyeliner, great colour, stays put, easy to use (as no sharpener required) and still easy enough to get off.

cottage Fingers crossed that this one lasts A good eyeliner which lasts all day. But there’s not much lead in pencil and runs out quickly

Maza21 excellent this eyeliner is excellent it stays great all day. I got this eyeliner in the M & S beauty box and loved it and have continued to use it

Ches 73 Very disappointed. Very disappointing. Crayon does not retract and therefore you are unaware of how much is left. Does not warrant the price tag. Will not purchase again.

AliceTheo Great, reliable and stays in place Always buy this eyeliner. Does not smudge below the eyes at all during the day. Really like it.

Stilaeyeliner Great product Second one I have bought now. It smudges well and doesn’t budge all day.

RedLab Kind to skin Nice & smooth doesn’t drag skin colour very pale so only 4 stars

1942girl Excellent Smudge Pencils I have been using these eye liners for years. I've tried many others but always come back to these. They smudge perfectly and give a lovely soft look which suits me fine. I recommend.

TonbridgeUK Still eye pencil Easy to apply. Smudge-able. Stays put but comes off with eye make up remover.

Zilpah Excellent eyeliner stick Mid-green colour goes on smoothly and is easy to use.