Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner 0.3g

Having bought other items in this range I was keen to try this item BUT was very disappointed indeed.

I first bought this product a couple of years ago and still buy it now whenever it runs out.

I have returned this. The part of the pencil which you apply, is inside the pencil and there is no way to extend it. Shame, I love the look of the colour, but it didn’t even protrude enough to try it. Some reviews did warn of this, but some seemed pleased, so I went for it

This is a lovely colour but it is way too hard to use on your eyes. Even on the back of my hand to try the colour it was painful to use, having to press so hard. Not suitable to use on delicate eye area where light strokes are needed. Shame.

Easy application and like the twist that opens the pencil so no sharpening. Will buy more colours

The eyeliner is very good, but I agree with the other comments saying the winding mechanism does not work. Why don’t they improve the design. I have tried three, two of which came in a gift box.

Have been using this for a few years. Good colour and stays put.

Bought this a couple of weeks ago and cant get it to work - have only used a few times as it wont propel.

I bought this and after one days use my eyes were red, swollen, and very crusty. Didn’t make the connection and after a week or so make-up free, reapplied eye liner and same thing happened. Don’t particularly have sensitive eyes / allergies but definitely avoid this colour if you do. Have used green equivalent and no problems - although this could be more related to fact that pencil was so hard it was virtually impossible to apply.

This is very very shiny with lots of glitter in it - that was NOT obvious from the description. It is also a very strange colour. I've tried dimming it down with a matt eyeshadow over the top with limited success. Not my best purchase and shows yet again the dangers of purchasing cosmetics without being able to try a tester.